Category Archives: Court Cases

HOA Board Director conflicts of interest (Castellammare litigation)

The Court of Appeal issued its decision affirming summary judgment in the long standing Castellammare litigation.  The action was filed in 2006 by Saied Kashani to challenge the  Castellammare Homeowners Association’s requirement that he erect story poles to determine the impact his … Continue reading

Posted in Court Cases, HOAs, Local Laws & Ordinances, Neighbor v. Neighbor, PVRC News | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

100% Attorney’s Fees Win in View Rights Case

The Turner Law Firm was awarded 100% of its attorney’s fees and costs in a view rights dispute.   The case is important because it concerns the reciprocal nature of statutory attorney’s fees provisions, including whether they apply if the defendant … Continue reading

Posted in Court Cases, HOAs, Local Laws & Ordinances, Neighbor v. Neighbor, PVRC News | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

example of preliminary injunction denied (Marquez Knolls)

Many view rights cases are effectively decided at the TRO or preliminary injunction stage, to stop construction of the new or bigger home or structure.   Thus, both sides have to present their best evidence at the beginning of the case. … Continue reading

Posted in Court Cases, Neighbor v. Neighbor, PVRC News | Tagged , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

injunction granted – for failure to obtain HOA’s Architectural Committee approval

The recent Tesoro del Valle Master Homeowners Association v. Griffin case provides a good example of power of a well-functioning HOA/ Architectural Control Committee to deny a homeowner’s construction project, and to its right and power to go to court for injunctive … Continue reading

Posted in Court Cases, HOAs, Local Laws & Ordinances, PVRC News | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

View Rights; Ocean Views; Trees; Spite Fences; and Jury Instructions

On April 15, 2011, the Fourth District of the Court of Appeal issued a decision reversing the San Diego Superior Court in a spite fence case. Vanderpol v. Starr, filed April 15, 2011, Fourth District, Div. One, Cite as D056599. The … Continue reading

Posted in Court Cases, Local Laws & Ordinances, Neighbor v. Neighbor | Leave a comment